The Rum Diary – 2011

Written and Directed by Bruce Robinson
Starring Johnny Depp, Aaron Eckhart, Michael Rispoli, Giovanni Ribisi, Amber Heard, Richard Jenkins

I had always wondered whether I should read any of Hunter S. Thompson’s stuff.  I had a quirky friend who had read him in High School and, before he went off the deep end, I found him to be rather funny.  ‘Round about 2005 when he decided he wasn’t going to live with the consequences of his bad lifestyle choices, I decided that reading his works was no longer necessary.  There is a line early on when Hunter’s alter-ego, Paul Kemp, gives advice to a man of recent acquaintance who is tired of his job:

“Why don’t you quit?  Life is full of exits.”

This is a clever line, to the makers of The Rum Diary.  They apparently think nothing of his decision to leave his loved ones in the lurch at the end.  To Johnny Depp and Bruce Robinson, Thompson is still a wacked-out folk hero rebel.  From Depp, this is not a surprise, as he already made the another Thompson movie, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, which bombed in 1999.  As for Robinson, I am still not sure he’s made a movie that has turned a profit, and I am utterly surprised that he got $40 million from someone to make this film.  It barely made half of its money back.  So at least this is consistent with Hunter’s other works made into movies.

The story is typical Thompson: booze, a new job, weird new friends, drugs and bastards.  The bastards, as in every case, are those who by nature or choice are in opposition to Thompson.  He has some sense of right and wrong, mixed with the drugs it is often hard to distinguish if it is real or by accident.  The natives are his purpose du jour.  He gets offers from the bastards (Eckhart in better clothes than everyone else) to help them make money.  Meanwhile he hangs out with his new, lowly, newspaper writing and drug addicted friends, getting in trouble with the locals while feeling a pious pity for them.

As for the friends, Ribisi is wasted simply by playing every other lowlife he’s portrayed in his career.  Rispoli actually does a credible job as Bob Sala, who is the resident true heart sad sack.  He is so believable, he almost makes the movie worth watching.  But not quite.

Depp is amusing, off and on, but we’ve seen this crap before, done better in other movies that take place in the Caribbean.  We get it, Depp.  In the immortal words of Marc Hochman, “We gotcha.”  We’re all impressed that you can play someone in an altered state.  Now try playing sober.

(** out of *****)


  1. Thanks for the post… For some reason this movie did not take off and I know several people who do not like it. For me, it was the perfect movie. I loved every second and have watched it 3 times since… I guess I am a little “off”!

    • Jason, I appreciate your comments and the time taken to read our site. You are not “off,” at all, but in sync with many who enjoyed Thompson’s work. I found the film clever at times, but when considering how his life ended, I think he took the easy way throughout. Not much to follow imho.

      Thanks again and hope to see you again on here,

      • How did he pass away? I am getting ready to watch an interview with him from the Charlie Rose archives.

      • He committed suicide. He had varying medical conditions, including hip replacement, but nothing of an extremely painful or desperate kind. Life was getting harder and he did not want to deal with it. His son, daughter in law and grandson were in the next room. Kind of an a-hole move, but then suicide is usually an egregious act heaped on the survivors.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s