Many are hailing this coming week’s X-Men: First Class as the best Marvel movie ever. Everything I have seen so far looks fantastic. Now is as good a time as any to check what we’ve seen so far from the X-Men Series of films. This list will be comprehensive within the next couple of weeks, but for now, we will just cover the ones that have been released and are available on Blue Ray and DVD.
Directed by Bryan Singer
Starring Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellan, Hugh Jackman, Famke Janssen, James Mardsen, Bruce Davidson, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos, Anna Paquin, Ray Park, Tyler Mane, Halle Berry
Screenplay by David Hayter based on a story by Bryan Singer and Tom DeSanto and characters by Jack Kirby and Stan Lee
Review Solid basis as the foundation for the series. The strengths of this film lay in the casting of McKellen and Stewart as kings on the chessboard of a game of mutants. They take their time introducing new characters, and they can afford to do this with the introduction of Hugh Jackman as Wolverine. His delivery is straight Clint Eastwood, but it is the best stroke of casting luck this film could’ve had. After Dougray Scott, the original choice, chose to go be the bad guy in the unremarkable Mission: Impossible II, the director Bryan Singer settled on Jackman. The rest is cinematic history. Janssen is excellent as the tortured Jane Grey, even if James Mardsen seems a little too young to be her husband. Or maybe just too short. The brilliance of the movie, however, is that they are able to use McKellen and Stewart so effectively. The only stretch in casting is Halle Berry as Storm. The weak actress lacks any sort of presence at all as the supposedly powerful Storm. It would have been nice to see a real actress, like, Angela Bassett, wreak havoc with the character. Apparently she refused the role.
Best Sequence – Magneto (McKellen) exhibits how far he is willing to go beyond Professor X (Stewart) to get what he wants at the train station. All of those humans with their guns. Nice to see Wolverine so helpless.
Worst Sequence – Pretty much all of Halle Berry’s scenes with that wig make one feel like they are watching a B-Grade film.
Rating – ****
Director Bryan Singer
Starring Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellan, Hugh Jackman, Famke Janssen, James Mardsen, Bruce Davidson, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos, Anna Paquin, Halle Berry, Brian Cox, Alan Cumming, Aaron Stanford, Shawn Ashmore, Kelly Hu, Michael Reid-McKay
Screenplay by David Hayter, Michael Dougherty, Dan Harris based on a story by Bryan Singer, David Hayter, Zak Penn and characters by Jack Kirby and Stan Lee
Review – A more comprehensive film that takes advantage of the strengths of the first picture and adds glimpses of other characters, while expounding on the others enough to make them well-rounded. Jackman grows exponentially in a role that, while not as entirely a leader, a damn good captain. McKellen and Stewart again are solid, if less of a focus as before. Cox provides the perfect bad guy, using hypocritical methods to get what he wants, all while providing enough of a sly grin to let you know he really enjoys it. Speaking of enjoying it, Romijn expands her performance to match Mystique’s cult figure status. Alan Cumming, as Nightcrawler, plays the most normal creature of his career. Seeing him as religious is ironic. Halle’s wig is better…slightly. The acting isn’t any better. Good script, tight direction, well-paced. This is the jewel in the crown of the X-Men universe thus far.
Best Sequence – Wolverine absolutely kicking ass unrepentantly as the men of Stryker (Cox) attack Xavier’s School. This is Wolverine as all X-Men fans dreamed of seeing him.
Worst Sequence – Adamantium boiling for 15 years is kind of a stretch, but the fire guy is mostly annoying…mostly.
Rating – (****1/2)
Directed by Brett Ratner
Starring Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellan, Hugh Jackman, Famke Janssen, James Mardsen, Bruce Davidson, Rebecca Romijn-Stamos, Anna Paquin, Halle Berry. Kelsey Grammer, Michael Murphy, Vinnie Jones, Bill Duke, Ben Foster, Ellen Page, Shawn Ashmore, Ken Leung, Aaron Stanford, Eric Dane
Written by Simon Kinberg, Zak Penn based on characters by Jack Kirby and Stan Lee
Review – After an organic pairing of the first and second films, this one feels overwhelmed by new characters and too many factions. The disappearance of Cyclops feels like someone who was called off set to another movie. From there, the handling of Phoenix / Jane Grey is a mess. It was powerful enough to have been a multi-movie arc, but instead just jumps around here and there, dotting the storyline like a ghost. The “death” of several of the characters feel like cheats, especially when you see mutants (like Toad) who died in the first film appear in the third. That said, Berry is better than she was in either of the first two films, but that does not say much. Storm and Wolverine are showcased probably too much, due mainly to the economy of characters. I am not sure how the brotherhood ended up in a tent city out in the woods. The end is a hodgepodge of one note power shows. It’s hard to fault Director Ratner too much for any of the issues, as he was thrown into the mix late in the game. It’s really not a bad movie, but it certainly is not a very good one.
Best Sequence – Hard to say. So much seemed over the top, nothing was really that entertaining. It would be a tie, I guess, with Wolverine versus the man with regenerating arms (“Grow a new pair of those.”) and Kitty Pryde versus the Juggernaut.
Worst Sequence – The Golden Gate Bridge? Really? Really dumb. To top it off, they give McKellen’s Magneto the dumbest line of all time: “Charles always wanted to build bridges.” He must have absolutely cringed.
Rating – (***)
Directed by Gavin Hood
Starring Hugh Jackman, Liev Schreiber, Danny Huston, Dominic Monaghan, Ryan Reynolds, Will.i.am, Kevin Durand, Lynn Collins, Taylor Kitsch
Written by David Benioff, Skip Woods
Review – The fact that this is just another ensemble of mutants teaming together and falling apart does not detract from the good performances. I thought it was nuts to have Sabretooth back, but hiring Schreiber in any capacity was a masterstroke. Overall, the story is passable, but having Huston, Schreiber and especially Reynolds along helps to push the material up a notch. Jackman shows a great early version of the role that made him a star. His multi-layered performance shows how lucky they were that he landed on the producer’s doorsteps for the first movie.
Best Sequence – Seeing the early version of Deadpool (Reynolds) in top form, massacring a room full of gun-firing Nigerians with only two swords. It beats anything else by a long shot.
Worst Sequence – Not sure which is worse, killing Grandma with a shot to the head, or the ensuing motorcycle chase which leads to the incredibly ridiculous stunt with the helicopter.
Rating – (***1/2)
Directed by Matthew Vaughn
Starring Michael Fassbender, James McAvoy, Rose Byrne, January Jones, Jennifer Lawrence, Oliver Platt, Kevin Bacon
Written by Ashley Edward Miller, Zack Stenz, Jane Goldman and Matthew Vaughn
Review – here
Best Sequence – Magneto finally moves the coin…much to Sebastian Shaw’s dismay.
Worst Sequence – The Beast outfit almost outdoes Hoult’s performance, and who can forgive the fact that they did not kill off Michael Ironside.
Rating – (****1/2)